Providing HR professionals with the latest industry news, best practices, and thought leadership to help navigate the ever-changing landscape of human resources.
When we began looking at workplace conflict, I was interested in understanding what HR professionals actually experience day to day, not just the rare incidents that capture public attention.
The first finding was encouraging. Ask HR professionals whether they feel safe at work, and the answer is overwhelmingly yes. A full 97% say exactly that. In fact, a quarter tell us the idea of conflict escalating in the workplace simply never crosses their mind.
At first glance, those numbers suggest most workplaces are safe. But when we looked more closely at HRCI's State of HR data, a different picture emerged, one in which conflict is far more common than many people assume and rarely resembles the incidents that make national headlines. Creating a safe workplace means more than preventing catastrophic events. It also means fostering an environment where employees feel both physically and psychologically safe every day.
Major tragedies understandably receive the most attention. Fortunately, those cases remain exceedingly rare. Far more common are the everyday conflicts that shape employees' experiences and, if left unresolved, can gradually become more serious.
Nearly four in 10 HR professionals in our survey reported witnessing some form of aggressive or criminal behavior at work, including verbal arguments, hostile situations, direct threats, property damage, physical altercations, or the presence of weapons.
To better understand how workplace conflict presents itself, HRCI examined what HR professionals are experiencing today and the practical steps organizations can take to respond. We recently published those findings in Keeping the Workplace Safe, a new report that explores the realities of workplace conflict and practical strategies for creating safer workplaces.
Broken down, the reality of workplace conflict looks like this: 33% of HR professionals have witnessed bullying; 29% have witnessed aggressive acts; 28% have witnessed threats, physical altercations, or weapons; and 20% have witnessed substance use.
These findings suggest workplace conflict is not an isolated issue. A meaningful share of HR professionals have witnessed these situations firsthand, often more than once.
What strikes me most is that conflict of this kind doesn't always look dramatic. Bullying, in particular, is not always a shouting match. It can be an employee's voice consistently going unheard. It can be someone's work being quietly reassigned or credited to someone else. It can be a person being left off a committee or excluded from decisions that directly affect their job.
None of these examples may rise to the level of a single reportable incident. Yet over time, repeated behaviors like these can contribute to more serious workplace issues if they are left unaddressed. Workplace conflict should be handled immediately and never be treated as routine. Left unresolved, it carries real consequences for employee well-being, including increased anxiety, absenteeism, turnover, and lower productivity.
External factors are also finding their way into the workplace. Politics is one example. Almost half of our survey respondents reported experiencing some form of political tension at work. Thirty-five percent have witnessed or heard a political argument, 14% have seen an employee leave a job because of political tension, 16% have seen politics affect a client relationship, and 9% say it has affected hiring.
Regardless of the broader political environment, organizations remain responsible for creating workplaces built on respect, professionalism, and psychological safety. HR plays a central role in establishing those expectations and responding consistently when they're challenged.
It's also important to place the most severe incidents in context. Government data shows workplace fatalities have declined in recent years, and most result from accidents rather than intentional acts of violence. While every incident is significant, these events remain exceptionally uncommon compared with the day-to-day conflicts HR professionals report experiencing.
The more frequent challenges, including bullying, aggression, political tension, and substance use, deserve sustained attention because of both their prevalence and their impact on employees and organizations.
Understanding the problem is only the first step. The next is building an organizational response that's practical, integrated, and sustained over time.
The most effective workplace safety strategies don't rely on a single policy or annual training session. They combine prevention, education, clear expectations, and ongoing support into an organizational culture where employees know how concerns will be handled and trust that leaders will respond appropriately.
Every organization should begin with a comprehensive, written conflict prevention plan that is supported by regular training. Employees should understand what behaviors are unacceptable, how to report concerns, and what happens after a report is made. Just as important, organizations should regularly review and update these policies so they continue to reflect evolving workplace realities.
Supervisors play a critical role. They're often the first to notice behavioral changes that may signal escalating distress. Training managers to recognize warning signs and respond with empathy, consistency, and appropriate resources can help address issues long before they become crises.
Support systems matter as well. Employee Assistance Programs can help employees address personal challenges, including anxiety, depression, substance use disorders, financial stress, and family concerns, before those issues affect workplace relationships or performance. Research consistently demonstrates their value, but organizations shouldn't assume employees will automatically take advantage of them. Building awareness and reducing stigma are just as important as offering the benefit itself.
Employees also need accessible, confidential ways to raise concerns. Open communication with managers, HR, and leadership, along with anonymous reporting options where appropriate, encourages people to speak up early, when concerns are often easier to resolve.
Organizations should also make workplace safety an ongoing process rather than a one-time initiative. Regular risk assessments help leaders evaluate changing workplace dynamics and identify emerging concerns before they escalate. Some organizations have strengthened this work through multidisciplinary teams that bring together expertise from HR, legal, security, and employee well-being to evaluate potential risks from multiple perspectives.
While catastrophic events remain rare, organizations should still be prepared for them. Our research found that nearly one-third of organizations have no active shooter plan in place, and among those that provide training, nearly half rate that training as fair, poor, or very poor. Those findings reinforce a broader point: preparedness should extend from the everyday conflicts employees experience to the rare emergencies every organization hopes never occur.
The data tells a consistent story. Workplace conflict is common, often subtle, and increasingly shaped by pressures that extend beyond the workplace itself. At the same time, many organizations remain underprepared, not only for high-profile emergencies but also for the everyday situations that have the greatest impact on employees' experiences.
Creating a safer workplace requires more than policies or emergency plans. It requires an organizational culture that addresses conflict early, supports respectful workplace behavior, and treats safety as an ongoing leadership responsibility rather than a periodic compliance exercise.
The organizations that do this well are better positioned not only to reduce risk, but also to build healthier, more resilient workplaces where employees can do their best work.
About the Author Amy Schabacker Dufrane, Ed.D., SPHR, CAE, is CEO of HRCI, where she drives strategic conversations about building high-performing HR teams. An award-winning thought leader at the intersection of talent strategy and continuous learning, Dr. Dufrane is a celebrated keynote speaker on the human side of successful business strategy.
Related Learning & Resources